Every book needs a design, but not every book needs the same kind of design. Sometimes, hiring a premium book layout designer is the smartest money you’ll spend. Other times, you can pull off a great designer DIY without sacrificing quality. But the real challenge is knowing which is which.

And honestly, book design isn’t just a “pretty cover.” It’s the complete package, from cover art, typography, book layout, branding, and even technical details like margins and image placement. It shapes how your story feels, how it’s received, and whether readers see it as worth their time and money.

In this blog, we will be having the DIY vs professional debate, so you know exactly when to invest in book design for a refined and market-ready result, along with some million-dollar questions like should you design your book yourself, or hire someone? And when you can safely improvise without hurting your book’s chances.

Whether you’re launching a debut novel, printing a family memoir, or testing ideas with beta readers, you’ll leave here with a strategy that matches your goals, budget, and skills. So, let’s get started!

Key Takeaways

• Good book design, from cover to book layout, is the first promise you make to your reader, and it shapes how your work is perceived before they read a single word.
• Designer DIY can work for small projects or test runs, but professional design ensures market-ready quality and saves you from costly mistakes.
• Hiring a premium book layout designer is like investing in market positioning, readability, and brand trust.
• A hybrid approach lets you DIY some elements while using book layout design services for high-impact areas, balancing budget and quality.
• The right design approach, whether DIY or book design services, depends on your goals, audience, and how competitive your market is.

What Exactly Is “Book Design”

If you’ve ever thought, “I’ve typed my book in Word, added page numbers, and hit save, so I’m basically done, right?” Well, no. Book design is a whole art of its own, and it comes in two major parts:

Cover Design

This is the face your book shows the world. It’s not just about showing your title over a pretty picture. A proper cover design balances:

• Typography that fits your genre
• Imagery or illustration that sparks curiosity without confusing readers.
• Composition that works both in print and as a thumbnail on online stores.

It also plays a huge role in branding. Your cover communicates whether you’re a romance author, a thought leader, a fantasy world-builder, or a DIY home improvement guru.

Interior Layout

The inside of your book, also called the book layout, is where readers will spend the majority of their time, and it’s shockingly easy to get wrong. We’re talking:

• Margins and line spacing that are easy on the eyes.
• Consistent typography for body text and headings.
• Chapter openings that look intentional.
• Image placement that doesn’t cut off diagrams or shunt a photo awkwardly onto the next page.

A strong interior layout affects readability, pacing, and how professional your work feels. Even the most gripping plot can be sabotaged by small text or mismatched fonts.

Why It Matters More Than You Think

A well-designed book does three important things:

• Improves reader experience – they’re not fighting the page to enjoy your words.
• Positions your book in the market – it looks like it belongs alongside other professionally produced titles.
• Boosts sales and reviews – readers are more likely to buy (and recommend) something that looks worth their money.

In short, good design makes your words easier to trust. Bad design makes them easier to ignore. And if your book layout looks like it was put together poorly with a glue stick, trust me, people will notice.

The DIY Approach: Your Time to Shine or Crash and Burn

For some authors, the idea of DIY book design is exciting, complete creative control, no invoices from book layout designers, and the satisfaction of saying, “Yes, I did the whole thing myself.”

For others, it’s more about necessity. The budget’s tight, the book’s a passion project, and paying for premium book design services just isn’t in the cards right now.

Why Authors DIY

Honestly, most people DIY for one of three reasons:

• Budget: Hiring professional book layout design services can run anywhere from a few hundred to a few thousand dollars, depending on complexity.
• Creative Freedom: You want exactly what’s in your head, without compromise.
• Challenge: You like learning new skills.

Many authors successfully pulled off a DIY design, and others created something that looked like a church newsletter from 1997. The difference usually comes down to tools, skills, and an honest self-assessment.

Common DIY Tools

If you’re going down the “designer DIY” path, these are the platforms most indie authors use:

• Canva – Great for beginners, with pre-made templates for covers and interiors, but limited in advanced print specs.
• Vellum – Popular for interior book layout, especially for eBooks, with clean formatting options.
• Affinity Publisher – Affordable alternative to InDesign, with professional capabilities.
• Adobe InDesign – Industry standard for serious book layout design services.

Skills You’ll Need to Pull it Off

DIY book design isn’t just about choosing a pretty font. At minimum, you’ll want to understand:

• Color theory (how colors influence mood and readability).
• Typography basics (why Comic Sans is never okay).
• File formatting (exporting print-ready PDFs, bleed settings, CMYK vs. RGB).
• Trim sizes (so you don’t end up with a cover that’s “almost” the right size).

Pitfalls of DIY

Here’s where reality hits:

• Looking Amateur – Readers can spot self-made covers and sloppy interiors instantly.
• Poor Readability – Too much text per page, bad line spacing, or inconsistent fonts can strain readers’ eyes.
• Technical Errors – Incorrect margins, missing bleeds, or low-res images can lead to printing disasters.

DIY can be rewarding if you’ve got the patience, the tools, and the design eye. But without those, you risk creating a product that turns people away before they’ve even read the blurb.

The Professional Approach: Why It’s Not Just ‘Paying for Pretty’

Hiring a professional for your book layout design services isn’t just about making your book look nice. It’s about handing it to someone who knows exactly how to make it look market-ready, a book that feels like it belongs in the same league as titles from big-name publishers.

What Professional Designers Actually Do

A good premium book design service goes far beyond choosing a cool font or throwing an image behind your title. They handle:

1. Market Positioning – Understanding your genre’s design conventions and reader expectations so your book fits in while standing out.
2. Typography Mastery – Choosing typefaces that match your tone, improve readability, and create visual hierarchy.
3. Layout Expertise – Perfect margins, clean chapter openings, balanced spacing, and thoughtful image placement.
4. Technical Precision – Setting up files for printers or eBook platforms, including bleeds, crop marks, spine width, and ISBN placement.
5. Cross-Format Consistency – Ensuring your print version and eBook have a cohesive look, even though they’re built differently.

The Intangibles

Professional book layout designers have seen it all. They know what works, what doesn’t, and how to fix problems you didn’t even know existed. They’ve kept up with design trends, know what sells in your niche, and have relationships with printers that can save you time.

They also give you something you can’t buy, i.e., peace and assurance. Knowing your book meets industry standards means you can focus on your launch instead of worrying about whether your margins are “weird.”

What It Costs

Rates vary, depending on your requirements. However, some designers charge flat rates, others by the hour, but most reputable ones will include a set number of revisions and final files optimized for your printer or platform.

Why It’s Worth It

Yes, you could grab something off the rack (DIY templates), but a professional makes sure it fits you perfectly and flatters from every angle. They also know where to put the ISBN barcode so it doesn’t look like a tramp stamp.

The Difference, Side-by-Side

At first glance, both DIY and professional book design involve someone sitting at a computer, clicking around, and making your words look nice. However, the gap between the two approaches is a lot different. Technically, it’s like two recipes with the same ingredients, but wildly different results.

Time Investment

DIY – Expect to spend weeks (or months) learning the tools, experimenting with fonts, and troubleshooting formatting errors. You’ll watch more YouTube tutorials than you ever thought possible, and you’ll probably redo the layout three or four times before it feels “okay.”

Professional – Most experienced book layout designers can deliver a complete, polished design in days or weeks, depending on the scope. You hand over your manuscript, have a few discussions, approve proofs, and it’s done.

Skill Level

DIY – Trial and error is the main learning path. If you already have an eye for design and some software experience, you might create something respectable. If not, you risk mismatched fonts, awkward spacing, or covers that unintentionally scream “self-published.”

Professional – Years of experience, formal training, and industry know-how. They have mastered typography, composition, and file prep, and they’ll get it right the first time.

End Results

DIY – Can be anywhere from “surprisingly great” to “please don’t put my name on this.” Consistency is the biggest challenge. What looks good on your laptop may print poorly if your files aren’t set up correctly.

Professional – Consistently refined, market-ready, and designed to industry standards. Your book will look like it belongs alongside traditionally published titles.

A Quick Comparison

Feature	DIY	Professional
Cost	Low upfront, potential hidden reprint costs	Higher upfront, fewer hidden costs
Control	100% yours (for better or worse)	Shared, with expert guidance
Learning Curve	Steep	Minimal for you
Market Readiness	Hit or Miss	Reliable
Time to Completion	Weeks to months	Days to weeks

If your goal is total creative control and budget savings, DIY might be worth the grind. If your goal is to launch with something polished, trustworthy, and competitive, a premium book design service will almost always get you there faster and with fewer headaches.

When to Invest?

There are plenty of situations where hiring a premium book layout designer or investing in professional services is the difference between your book quietly gathering dust and it actually getting noticed. These are the moments when it’s worth every cent to bring in the experts.

1. Your Book Is a Commercial Product, Not Just a Personal Project

If you’re planning to sell your book and you want people who don’t share your last name to actually buy it, your design needs to look professional from the start. Readers expect certain standards, whether they consciously realize it or not. If your book doesn’t meet those expectations, they’ll move on.

2. You’re Entering a Competitive Market

Romance, fantasy, thrillers, business books. These categories are like crowded freeways at rush hour. Your cover and layout have seconds to grab attention. A professional understands your genre’s design language and how to make your book stand out without looking off-brand.

3. Your Skills Are Minimal, but Your Goals Are Big

It’s one thing to DIY a poetry collection for family and friends. And it’s another thing to DIY a commercial release when you’ve never opened InDesign in your life. If your ambition is high but your technical skills are shaky, you’ll save yourself weeks of frustration by hiring a pro.

4. You’re Targeting Bookstores or Libraries

Bookstores and libraries are choosy. They’re looking for books that look like they belong on their shelves. That means professional typesetting, industry-standard trim sizes, proper spine text alignment, and no glaring design faux pas.

5. You Want a Long-Term Author Brand

If this is the first of several books you plan to publish, your design is also branding. A pro can establish a consistent, recognizable look across your titles, one that builds reader loyalty and brand recognition.

When to Improvise?

Not every book demands a premium book design service or the full attention of a layout designer. Sometimes, a thoughtful and resourceful DIY approach is exactly what you need, as long as you do it with intention.

1. Personal or Passion Projects

If your book is meant for a small audience, say, a family memoir, a poetry book for friends, or a local fundraiser cookbook, going DIY can be more than enough. The stakes are lower, and you can still make it attractive without spending thousands.

2. Early Test Runs for Beta Readers

When you’re not ready for a full public release, you don’t need to pay for a high-end layout just yet. An improvised and clean design gets the job done for test copies, allowing you to gather feedback before committing to book layout design services for the final edition.

3. Limited-Edition Giveaways

If you’re printing a short run for a conference, school visit, or niche event, DIY can save you money while still letting you control the look. As long as you keep it simple and readable, your audience will appreciate the gesture without expecting a bookstore-level finish.

The Hybrid Approach

If going fully DIY feels risky, but hiring a premium book layout designer for the entire project feels like too big a spend, there’s a sweet spot. The hybrid approach! It’s where you do part of the work yourself, and a professional steps in to handle the parts that matter most.

How It Works

Option 1: DIY the Interior, Hire a Pro for the Cover

Cover attracts the readers. Which is why they have to grab attention, fit genre norms, and still look unique. Many authors save on costs by formatting their own interior and paying for a professionally designed cover.

Option 2: DIY the Cover, Hire a Pro for the Interior

Less common, but sometimes useful for authors with a strong visual background who can create a cover themselves but want the interior layout to be handled by someone with deep typography and formatting expertise.

Option 3: Use a Professional Template, Then Customize

Some affordable book design services offer ready-made and genre-specific templates that you can tweak. You get professional foundations without the full price tag of a custom design.

Why It Works

The hybrid approach gives you the cost savings of DIY while still leveraging the market insight and technical know-how of a professional. You’re not handing over your entire budget, but you’re also not risking a full-scale design disaster.

Conclusion

At the end of the day, your book is a product, an experience, and, in many cases, a calling card for your brand as an author. And just like you wouldn’t show up to a black-tie event in pajamas, you shouldn’t send your manuscript into the world without a design that does it justice.

The choice between DIY vs professional design isn’t about ego or snobbery. It’s about matching your goals, budget, and skills to the right approach. If you’re launching into a competitive market, chasing bookstore distribution, or building a long-term author brand, investing in our premium book design services or our professional layout designer can be the best approach. However, if you’re creating something for a smaller, personal audience, or testing the waters before a big release, we can help you with that too!

And remember, “when to invest” and “when to improvise” aren’t set in stone. You can mix approaches, start small and upgrade, or outsource only the elements that will make the biggest impact.

But whatever path you choose, remember that your book’s design isn’t an afterthought. It’s the first promise you make to your reader. Make it a promise worth keeping.

Frequently Asked Questions

What’s the difference between DIY and professional book design?

DIY design means creating your own cover and book layout, while professional services use experienced designers to deliver a polished, market-ready product.

When should I invest in premium book design services?

Invest when your book is a commercial product, targeting competitive markets, or aiming for bookstore and library placement.

Can a DIY approach still look professional?

Yes, if you have solid design skills, the right tools, and follow industry standards for book layout and cover design.

What’s a hybrid book design approach?

It’s when you DIY some elements and use book layout design services for high-impact areas like the cover or complex formatting.

Why does book design matter so much for sales?

Professional design builds trust, improves readability, and positions your book alongside other professionally produced titles, increasing sales potential.

---

About Author

Hi, my name is Zachary Stone  I’m a book marketing nut — or, as I like to call myself, a “Shelf Marketer.” No, I don’t sell wooden shelves; I market the books that are left forgotten on them. If you want your book to be the next bestseller, I am your go-to person. I am here to remind you that it’s not just about writing a great story — it’s about building a buzz among people with great campaigns.